Review: Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson

July 18, 2013     The Bluestocking Bookworm     Books, Books I've Read, Reading, Reviews

WintergirlsWintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson
Read: June 1 – June 2, 2013
Personal read.

Goodreads Book Blurb: Lia and Cassie are best friends, wintergirls frozen in matchstick bodies, competitors in a deadly contest to see who can be the skinniest. But what comes after size zero and size double-zero? When Cassie succumbs to the demons within, Lia feels she is being haunted by her friend’s restless spirit.

My Opinion: I had a hard time reading this one, but at the same time I couldn’t put it down.

Story time! Last summer, my husband and I went to our favorite Chinese restaurant to get some take-out. See, we love food. We eat it pretty much constantly. As I type this, I am eating s’mores trail mix with no real thought for calorie count or fat content. I have never really loved my body, but I have also never hated it. And I love food. But I digress. We stand at the counter and order the food from the same little Chinese woman who always takes our order. As we turn away and go to sit and wait, she congratulates me and asks me when I was due. Except I wasn’t pregnant. The days following that comment were the closest I have ever come to feeling like Lia does in Wintergirls. I weighed myself obsessively, I didn’t want to eat, and when I did eat, I obsessed over what I was eating and would it make me gain weight.

Being chronically ill, I can’t exercise the way most people can. Exercise actually makes me feel worse, not rejuvenated… So when I got sick a few years ago, it killed the little bit of physical activity I was able to manage. And I gained weight. And I hated it. I still do, but I am learning to manage a little better. But even with all that, the closest I have ever come to living with an eating disorder is a week after someone told me I looked pregnant.

Wintergirls triggered the heck out of me. Laurie Halse Anderson doesn’t sugar-coat the realities of hating your body. In 278 pages I was introduced to what my life could have been like if I had been pushed just a tiny bit harder. And it was scary.

From a writing standpoint, I found Lia to be a little flat. I wished that she had something going on besides anorexia and self-harm. It seemed a little one-dimensional to me. Laurie Halse Anderson has made some prose choices that were distracting at times. Wintergirls tended to read like one of my blog entries circa 2005, when I was a teenager and trying too hard to be deep and dreamy at the same time. And no, no amount of money will make me unearth those blog entries.

Bottom Line: In a sense I felt like Lia was her disease, and that made her fall a little flat. But Laurie Halse Anderson pulls no punches when talking about anorexia, and she paints a very real (and triggering) picture. Even with the distracting prose.

4 responses to “Review: Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson

  1. For the last two days, it seems like everywhere I look there’s a little reminder to read this book. I’m a Laurie Halse Anderson fan – I loved Speak, and your review has just done it for me. I’m going to go pick this one up. Tomorrow.

    Should I be scared?

    • Hey Tanya, thanks for the comment! This book has made a fan out of me, and I will definitely be checking out her other books. I wouldn’t say to be scared, but if anorexia has any potential to trigger you, definitely be wary because the book is very raw.

Talk bookish to me!